OneFS File Locking and Concurrent Access

There has been a bevy of recent questions around how OneFS allows various clients attached to different nodes of a cluster to simultaneously read from and write to the same file. So it seemed like a good time for a quick refresher on some of the concepts and mechanics behind OneFS concurrency and distributed locking.

File locking is the mechanism that allows multiple users or processes to access data concurrently and safely. For reading data, this is a fairly straightforward process involving shared locks. With writes, however, things become more complex and require exclusive locking, since data must be kept consistent.

OneFS has a fully distributed lock manager that marshals locks on data across all the nodes in a storage cluster. This locking manager is highly extensible and allows for multiple lock types to support both file system locks as well as cluster-coherent protocol-level locks, such as SMB share mode locks or NFS advisory-mode locks. OneFS also has support for delegated locks such as SMB oplocks and NFSv4 delegations.

Every node in a cluster is able to act as coordinator for locking resources, and a coordinator is assigned to lockable resources based upon a hashing algorithm. This selection algorithm is designed so that the coordinator almost always ends up on a different node than the initiator of the request. When a lock is requested for a file, it can either be a shared lock or an exclusive lock. A shared lock is primarily used for reads and allows multiple users to share the lock simultaneously. An exclusive lock, on the other hand, allows only one user access to the resource at any given moment, and is typically used for writes. Exclusive lock types include:

Mark Lock:  An exclusive lock resource used to synchronize the marking and sweeping processes for the Collect job engine job.

Snapshot Lock:  As the name suggests, the exclusive snapshot lock which synchronizes the process of creating and deleting snapshots.

Write Lock:  An exclusive lock that’s used to quiesce writes for particular operations, including snapshot creates, non-empty directory renames, and marks.

The OneFS locking infrastructure has its own terminology, and includes the following definitions:

Domain: Refers to the specific lock attributes (recursion, deadlock detection, memory use limits, etc) and context for a particular lock application. There is one definition of owner, resource, and lock types, and only locks within a particular domain may conflict.

Lock Type: Determines the contention among lockers. A shared or read lock does not contend with other types of shared or read locks, while an exclusive or write lock contends with all other types. Lock types include:
• Advisory
• Anti-virus
• Data
• Delete
• Mark
• Oplocks
• Quota
• Read
• Share Mode
• SMB byte-range
• Snapshot
• Write

Locker: Identifies the entity which acquires a lock.

Owner: A locker which has successfully acquired a particular lock. A locker may own multiple locks of the same or different type as a result of recursive locking.

Resource: Identifies a particular lock. Lock acquisition only contends on the same resource. The resource ID is typically a LIN to associate locks with files.

Waiter: Has requested a lock, but has not yet been granted or acquired it.

Here’s an example of how threads from different nodes could request a lock from the coordinator:

1. Node 2 is selected as the lock coordinator of these resources.
2. Thread 1 from Node 4 and thread 2 from Node 3 request a shared lock on a file from Node 2 at the same time.
3. Node 2 checks if an exclusive lock exists for the requested file.
4. If no exclusive locks exist, Node 2 grants thread 1 from Node 4 and thread 2 from Node 3 shared locks on the requested file.
5. Node 3 and Node 4 are now performing a read on the requested file.
6. Thread 3 from Node 1 requests an exclusive lock for the same file as being read by Node 3 and Node 4.
7. Node 2 checks with Node 3 and Node 4 if the shared locks can be reclaimed.
8. Node 3 and Node 4 are still reading so Node 2 asks thread 3 from Node 1 to wait for a brief instant.
9. Thread 3 from Node 1 blocks until the exclusive lock is granted by Node 2 and then completes the write operation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *